Wednesday, September 19, 2007

An Open Letter to Worship Leaders and Song Writers

A. W. Tozer - "Without worship, we go about miserable."

I have been involved in worship music for over 25 years. I believe there is no higher calling for God's people than to worship Him. So very often we become so encompassed in our worship FOR the Lord we forget our first responsibility and call is our worship OF the Lord. In Acts chapter 13 it was as Paul and Barnabas were worshiping God that he said to the Antioch church, "Separate unto me Paul and Barnabas"

In recent years, we have seen like at no other time in history virtuosity come to the Christian music world. In an age where most listen to music with their eyes, it is a joy to see such a talented and careful group of young musicians and songwriters on the scene. But here is my challenge to the talented songwriters: Write worship songs that are Christocentric!

Last week I went into my local Christian bookstore and asked for the three top worship albums. One album did a very good job at crafting tunes that were indeed directed to God. But unfortunately, the songs weren't very good. On the other side of the spectrum, I listened to a worship CD where the music was excellent but they centered around seeking more blessing, becoming more of a servant, capturing more of God, etc, etc,etc. In one song the writer used the word "I: no less than 55 times! And this from a person who is touring the country right now as a top worship leader!

While there is a place for admonishing ourselves in music to serve more, and to call each other out of complacency and into more of God, I respectfully submit it is not worship. And our spirits are deprived and starving for true worship.

The person of God and him alone is the desire of every person's heart. It is Him we want not what he can do for us.Jesus said, "Come unto Me and I will give you rest". He didn't say "I know where rest is and if you come to me I'll show you where it is!".

Look at the songs of Revelation. Chapter 4:10 "the twenty-four elders fall down before him who is seated on the throne and worship him who lives forever and ever. They cast their crowns before the throne, saying, 'Worthy are you, our Lord and God, to receive glory and honor and power, for you created all things, and by your will they existed and were created.'"

In Chapter 5:12 hey sang "Worthy is the Lamb who was slain, to receive power and wealth and wisdom and might and honor and glory and blessing!"

The focus is God and not a single mention of "I".

My fear is my challenge will fall on deaf ears but I'll give it any way: Write songs that bring us into His presence, are about Him and to Him. This will not be an easy task but try we must. Let's learn worship Him for what He has already done for us before we start asking for more.

“Worship is first and foremost for His benefit, not ours, though it is marvelous to discover that in giving Him pleasure, we ourselves enter into what can become our richest and most wholesome experience in life.”--Graham Kendrick

20 comments:

Pastor Tom Fuller said...

Steve: I could not agree more with your comments. You and I have had numerous conversations about this. Worship should be "musical prayers to God" rather than exhortations to one another or battle cries to the enemy.

I echo your challenge to song writers - please give us songs we can turn into prayers.

Tom said...

After time with Roby and Bob your creative juices will be flowing. So I say put a pen and a pick in the same hand. I bet you could come up with some good stuff!

Jeremy Killian said...

I agree that much of worship music focuses on us rather than Christ. What I don't really understand is your point that praise for God somehow doesn't praise Christ. Last time I checked my systematic theology, they were the same person. Do you think that Christ, who died so that we could have fellowship with God, honestly minds when we seek to praise the Father?

Love the post, btw...just some honest questions.

Anonymous said...

Hey Steve, Love your blog! I agree that much or most of what passes for worship these days is little more than an odd singing ritual before the preacher fella steps up, but I'm not sure I understand what makes a good worship song. Couldn't a Chrisocentric song include the word "I"? As in "I love You Lord", or "I need You?", or "I'm a good for nothing wretch without You". What are some examples of some true modern worship songs? I'm genuinely curious, as I've long been dissatisfied and unfulfilled in worship, but haven't known why, or what true worship really is. I want to worship Him in spirit and in truth, but I'm not sure how, or what that really even means.

Rob

Anonymous said...

Steve- Matthew 15:21-28
This woman, deperate and heartbroken, "came and WORSHIPPED Him saying, "Lord help ME!" (v.25) She was almost sent away by Christ's own disciples who were more than annoyed by her act of "worship" (v.23) But her humility and need proclamied the very glory of God. Jesus was blessed by her "self-centered" worship (v.28) "O woman great is your faith! Let it be to you as you desire."
When we come to Him with our needs we ARE worshiping Him because we are recognizing the fact that only God can "help me". In doing this we ARE proclaiming His power is above all. That is true worship.
Let's stop being worship critics, like the disciples, and just start worshiping!

-a humble worship leader

tomregan said...

It seems to me that Steve wasn't saying that praise for God and Christ are two different things. In fact I read his post as pleading for God-centered/Christ-centered worship, rather than songs that emphasize the worshiper, in which the One worshiped is not the central focus.

It's been rightly pointed out that the Psalmists often make reference to themselves. The problem is ultimately not the pronoun "I" in many contemporary songs, or the fact that the worshiper makes reference to him or herself. The problem, in my opinion, is that there is often little focus upon the great attributes of God himself. Often we sing about our feelings about God rather than God Himself.

A song that says, "Pull me deeper, pull me closer to you" may be the true heart of the worshiper. But I would say that our hearts and minds need to be attuned to the great character of the God to whom we desire to be pulled closer.

Perhaps a good way of evaluating the quality of our worship songs is to ask, "What does this song communicate about God's greatness? What about God may my heart latch on to and praise?"

True, the psalmists referred to themselves, and their worship included petitions to God. But every psalm is thoroughly God-centered. The songs are saturated from beginning to end with the great character and mighty deeds of God.

Steve is a worship leader too and he doesn't exclude any song that uses "I". But I think what he's driving at is our need for songs that hold up God as the central thrust of our worship. Can we sing, "God be merciful to me"? Absolutely. But if we sing that, we should also sing about the merciful God Himself, not merely make requests of him.

As for being worship critics--we shouldn't be unduly critical, but we also are called to be faithful to Scripture and discerning. If we never examine our worship and consider how we may be more faithful to our call as worshipers and to the pattern laid down in Scripture, then we may find ourselves singing songs that ultimately don't point us to the greatness of our God, but rather lead us to focus on ourselves. There is a place for considering if we're worshiping God in our music as we ought to.

Anonymous said...

I agree!
blessings-
-a humble worship leader

Steve Hopkins said...

Annon
Your comments and heart for worship are greatly appreciated. You mentioned "praise" and intimated that it interchangeably with "worship". Both are important. But praise is different than worship. Praise is talking about God, thanking Him, acknowledgeing him for who he is and His attributes. Worship, on the other hand, is much deeper and intimate. As, I am sure you know, the word means to "to kiss". And my point is a lot of what we call worship never reaches that stage of intimacy with God. We stop at "praise--talking about God.

Imagine you and your wife or girls friend. She loves you deply and desires a deep relationship with you. She wants a passionate kiss and an embrce from the one she loves but you just keep talking or acknowleding her beautiful hair, clothes, what ever. Well that's the difference between worship and praise. Both are good but what God desiresand is waiting for is the embrace.

Praise leads to worship The bible says to come into his courts with praise. It has a role, but we cannot stop at praise we must move on into worship--that initmacy with God.

I think of the OT tabernacle. First there was the court. The people would gather there. The High Pries would begin to move forwad into the Hly of Holies. First there was the altar, were sacrifice was made, then the barass laver. He would go into the Holy place but once a year, with blood before him, he would go ibto the most sacred place of all--the Holy of Holies. There, on top of the ark was the mercy seat and there he would sprinkle blood and commune with God in the most intimate way possible.

The bible calls us and enables us by the blood of Christ, to come to that same Holy place of awe and worship.

So to me there is a big difference between praise and worship. Praise is important and a wonderful part of my expereince with God. But I think our hearts and God desire more.

Anonymous said...

Humble worship leader,
A closer look at Matthew 15 would show that the context there was intercessory prayer. Jesus ignored her to draw her faith out, as demonstrated by her persistence. It was her persistence in asking Jesus to cast the demon out of her daughter that agitated the disciples and prompted them to ask Jesus to tell her to leave.

I've seen the settle turn in people's hearts as they begin to worship instead of God. This type of admonish should always stay on the forefront of our hearts.

Mike Golden
CC Sisters, OR

Anonymous said...

oops! Didn't preview my post carefully enough.

I've seen the settle turn in people's hearts as they begin to worship worship instead of God. This type of admonish should always stay on the forefront of our hearts.

that's better ......Mike

Anonymous said...

"...the subtle turn..."(?)

Anonymous said...

wow, I didn't know I could be so wrong about worship...to me it has always been so simple. What I shared from Matthew 15 really spoke to my heart, I wasn't sharing this to cause a debate, I just wanted to share what spoke to my heart in the Word. Your comments have quenched my spirit. What I thought was an act of worship has turned into something more confusing to me. I really didn't notice that this Gentile woman wasn't worshiping. It just reads like she was. You are all a lot more knowledgable than me about this stuff I guess. Oh well, I guess what I thought would be an encouragment has turned out to be more of a wordy discussion. I'm sorry for that. Thanks for your thoughts. I am a woman, so maybe I hear with my heart first. I will continue to humbly worship the One who is above all!....Just one more thought....We worship because He is alone worthy. I take comfort in the fact that somehow a mighty awesome God still hears this heart worship no matter how inadequate my words are.

-a humble worship leader

Steve Hopkins said...

Humble
I appreciate the fact that you worship the Lord in honsty and humility. It sounds like you do!
But just because we are singing songs about the Lord, or are sitting in a session and are personally moved by the Lord doesn't always mean worship. Moving, plesant personally yes, but not always worship. Again, there is a place for praise and prayers in a worship context but also a time when we are just singing to the Lord, exalting him for what he has done already--not ssking for more or, trying to create a moving environment. We are not trying to quench you or any one--simply trying to learn to appreciate our Lord and give Him the praise and glory He deserves. Does that help explain where I am coming from a little?

Anonymous said...

I have understood from the beginning where you are coming from...and I wholeheartedly agree on your points of what worship is. But on the other hand I believe that we should be careful not to become intimidating "worship police". Sitting back and counting how many times the word "I" is used in a worship song really does nothing productive in my heart. Worship isn't complicated it's an outpouring of praise to the One who alone is worthy of it. I have run to Jesus many times with a need on my heart but before anything else I worship Him. It looks to me like this is what the Gentile woman did too. Are you saying that she came and worshiped Him only because she was depserate and in need? I'm saying that she worshiped Him because she saw Who He was first and because of Who He was, He is able. In her act of worship there was both praise and petition. Some worship songs contain both and I believe that they still glorify God.
Anyway, I agree with your main point...more songs about HIM and for HIM! Amen to that. Take care friend!
In His Grace,
H.W.L.

B.Middleton said...

Actually, that is the point of this blog, if I am not mistaken. To think through and make comments on how Steve (as the author of this blog) is interpreting and commenting on things of the Lord from his role as Pastor and fellow traveler in the Lord. He can have insights and thoughts about things without becoming a "Policeman" (although he was :) ) My take is that he is lamenting not that there are other types of Christian music, but that there is so little of "Worship", as exampled in Revelation among others.

Steve Hopkins said...

Dr. Middleton, Ph.D
Thanks you sir for your comment. You stated the issue better than me. There is room for praise and prayer songs (by prayer songs I mean songs like "Make me a servant" or "I want more of you" or "I want to be more like Jesus" etc.) but there are so few Songs that truly worship God and ask for nothing in return. So much of what we call worship has the idea of giving it to get something in return. Again, the "me" oriented worship.

As you said, what I am asking from worship song leaders and writers are more songs that glorify God, are direted toward Him, rather than massage the worshipper. It is so difficut for us to truly worship without some expectation of return.

Ryan said...

Steve,

I also think that as pastors we must continually remind our people that "corporate worship through music" is only one aspect of worship...

Worship (to kiss) is a lifestyle of being absolutely consumed with Him. Worship through music is important but only a small portion of what worship truly is.

I believe people's unwillingness to truly worship corporately is only a manifestation of their lack of worship individually and daily.

Steve Hopkins said...

ryan
to be clear, in a church worship context there is room for prayer songs, exhortation songs, and statements of commitment, but there needs to be more time spend directing our attention to the Lord and exalting Him simply for His greatness, His Holiness. Where we don't just affirm our commitment, or ask for more strength, or encouragement; but where we honor him devoid of anything we any expectation of return. The irony is we can never out give God! If we, as Ps. 29 says, "Give unto the Lord the glory due his name" then the very things we need from Him will be given to us--without asking! We need less songs like "I want more of you" and "Im going to follow you all the days of my life" or ""Jesus hear my heart"--all good songs--and more of "I exalt you" and "You are Holy" and "Behold the God that leads us, day by day to worship His son" etc. That's my challenge to the worship community

Regarding your plagerization of my Guardian article (:-)) You know the rule of ministry: "The secret of creativity and originality is ones ability to hide his sources" Go for it and credit is not necessary

Tom Regan said...

As I like to say with regard to sermon preparation, I milk a lot of other people's cows but I churn my own butter.

linda said...

i love aw tozer's books i read them it the reading his yearning for Christ and His soul crying out for the living God is what i love to sit on the beach and pray those beautiful melodies and songs, in my heart to God....
For He is worthy and all things were created for Him...
at times when i sing worship to God or even consider the words i just weep before Him and tell Him God only you are worthy and only YOu can change me too...or whatever i just sing praise, prayers from heart to Him
that is what it is all about